Why Chris Van Hollen is a sensible choice for Senate majority leader

Maryland Democratic Sen. Chris Van Hollen’s bid to defeat Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., and become the new Senate majority leader is a long shot. But I hope he succeeds. New Democratic leadership in Washington is badly overdue.

Schumer has led Senate Democrats for a decade. His tenure is not without accomplishments — he helped corral the votes for former President Joe Biden’s most important legislative accomplishments, including the Inflation Reduction Act. He’s made some tricky but successful calls when recruiting Senate candidates for competitive races.

But as a leader of the Democratic opposition to President Donald Trump’s assault on democracy, he has often shown timidity when strength was needed. When Trump attempted to deport pro-Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil, Schumer was unable to offer a full-throated defense of free speech because he detested Khalil’s political views. In response to Trump’s imperial assaults on Venezuela and Iran, Schumer declined to object to Trump’s actions on the basis of international law or moral common sense, instead offering narrow demands regarding operational details and compliance with procedure. And he has on multiple occasions failed to ensure that Democrats held the line against Republicans in government shutdown standoffs. It doesn’t help that he oozes anti-charisma when trying to convince people he’s fit to lead the anti-Trump resistance.

Van Hollen also seems to have more of an appetite for confrontation with Trump.

The post-midterm period is a natural time for a changing of the guard. The Democrats have the wind at their back after their astonishing success, and they are debating what their legislative priorities should be and what kinds of accountability measures they should pursue against the Trump administration. Already some Senate Democrats are openly arguing that Schumer is not the right person for this next chapter. On Tuesday, Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., said, “The time is now for change, and I will not be supporting Chuck to be re-elected as the Democratic leader.” Standing alongside Sanders, Sen. Elissa Slotkin, D-Mich., didn’t rule out backing Schumer, but she said she would need to be persuaded. “Whoever wants my vote is going to have to show me a concrete plan that’s definitively different,” Slotkin said. “I’m a no until and unless I see that from anyone.”

Van Hollen seems well-suited to lead the charge. In addition to being more progressive than Schumer, he better matches the populist direction of his caucus. Van Hollen supports Medicare for all, efforts to restrict arm sales to Israel and a robust wealth tax. A lot of what a Senate majority leader does is strategic, but their ideological outlook matters. It could shape what kinds of legislation he thinks is worth prioritizing and persuading the caucus to rally behind. It also affects the party’s top-level messaging to the public about what the party stands for. And it might be why Van Hollen has promised, in a break from Schumer, not to weigh in on open-seat primaries, suggesting an openness to outsiders as the party undergoes a change spurred by progressive challengers.

Van Hollen also seems to have more of an appetite for confrontation with Trump. He was the first U.S. lawmaker to visit El Salvador’s notorious CECOT superprison. His meeting with Kilmar Abrego Garcia, who was illegally deported there in 2025, got tremendous attention — and modeled what it looks like when Democrats stand up for democracy and the rule of law even when it might be politically controversial or on an issue where Trump is (incorrectly) assumed to always have a winning hand.

Moderates in the party would have no need to panic; this isn’t a storming of the barricades by a political neophyte or an outsider eager to burn down the house. Van Hollen has been in national politics since 2003 and in the Senate for a decade, including a two-year stint helming the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee. As Joseph Geevarghese, executive director of Our Revolution, put it to Politico, “Van Hollen represents a bridge between the old guard — people who’ve been in office for a long time with a more moderate orientation — and the new generation that is coming into office.”

That position might be best summed up by Van Hollen’s reaction last September to Democratic Party leaders’ reluctance to back Zohran Mamdani after he won the Democratic primary for mayor of New York. “That kind of spineless politics is what people are sick of,” he warned. Meanwhile, Schumer never endorsed Mamdani, and he even refused to say whether he voted for him during Mamdani’s general election.

Van Hollen faces long odds. He says he has more than 10 commitments, but he would need a majority of the caucus in order to win (28 or 29 supporters, depending on the Alaska Senate results). But even if he doesn’t win, this challenge is a healthy one — and may set the stage for a bigger fight in 2028.

The post Why Chris Van Hollen is a sensible choice for Senate majority leader appeared first on MS NOW.

Source Author
Author: Source Author

From MS Now.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *