The Supreme Court already declined to review one of President Donald Trump’s two petitions against writer E. Jean Carroll. But he’s still pressing the high court to take up the other one — and he’s not alone. He has backing on this one from the Justice Department, which said the court’s intervention is “manifestly” warranted.
The already-denied petition had sought to challenge Carroll’s $5 million award from a jury that found Trump liable for sexually abusing her in 1996 and defaming her about it in 2022, when he was between his two presidential terms.
The pending petition involves a separate $83.3 million jury award for statements Trump made in 2019, during his first term. As with the $5 million case, the lower courts have rejected his legal arguments, and so he has turned to the high court.
This second petition could get denied like the first, but it has a couple of things going for it that the first one lacked: It presents a presidential immunity claim, and it has the DOJ’s support. That doesn’t mean it will succeed, but it keeps the finality of that larger award in question until the justices weigh in.
On the immunity front, Trump’s personal lawyers argued that he can’t be held liable for statements he made to the White House press “defending his character and fitness for the Presidency.” They said the trial jury and judge both improperly considered his official presidential acts.
The DOJ said the government should have been allowed to substitute itself in Trump’s place as defendant against Carroll in this civil litigation. Like the president’s immunity claim, the DOJ argued in its own petition that Trump should not be held personally liable for what it called “conduct that falls well within the President’s scope of office.”
In a brief opposing Supreme Court review, Carroll’s lawyers cited the first denial and said the court “should do the same here.”
They recalled that Trump had accused Carroll of lying to sell her book, had insinuated she had made other false accusations, and had said she would “pay dearly” and that she should “be careful” because she was “playing with very dangerous territory.” They said she “received thousands of messages — many mirroring petitioner’s rhetoric — replete with graphic images or imagery and threatening sexual violence or death.”
They said that whatever the outer limits are of a president’s responsibilities, “surely what petitioner inflicted on Ms. Carroll is beyond it.”
Importantly for legal purposes, they said Trump forfeited his immunity argument by failing to press it earlier. And they said that, because the government substitution argument didn’t come until after trial, that one is untimely, too.
Her lawyers urged the court not to entertain arguments from Trump and the DOJ that their intention is to protect the presidency, saying, “While this President may want this Court’s help, the Presidency does not need it.”
Trump and the DOJ filed their final reply briefs this week, giving their last arguments before the court decides whether to grant review. Continuing to harness the office of the presidency, Trump’s lawyers said in their reply that this case marks the nation’s first instance of monetary liability imposed on a president’s conduct in office. The DOJ said the lower court’s refusal to allow the post-trial government substitution is an “evident error” that, “coupled with the serious practical consequences it entails, manifestly warrants this Court’s intervention.”
The court could announce whether it will grant or deny review in the coming weeks. The justices scheduled the matter for consideration at one of their upcoming private conferences on Dec. 4. That doesn’t mean the court will make or announce its decision that day, but that’s the soonest we could hear if the justices are granting review. The court is not on a deadline to decide, and it sometimes considers petitions over the course of several conferences before announcing a decision. It takes four justices to grant review.
The post Trump and his DOJ make final plea for Supreme Court review of E. Jean Carroll appeal appeared first on MS NOW.
From MS Now.

Leave a Reply