In the 2010 midterms, Senate Republicans fared very well, with a net gain of six seats, but they fell short of winning a majority. GOP officials weren’t just frustrated about falling short of their goal; they also pointed to a handful of races — most notably the contests in Delaware, Nevada and Colorado — where Republicans appeared well positioned to win before ultimately falling short.
Sixteen years later, Democrats fared even better in the 2026 midterms, flipping control of the Senate with a net gain of nine seats, but like the 2010 Republicans, there’s a lot of intraparty talk about seats that were left “on the table.”
In Louisiana’s Senate race, for example, which both parties largely assumed would be a lopsided affair, farmer Jamie Davis, the Democratic nominee, ended up losing by less than 2 percentage points, prompting many in the party to second-guess whether they squandered an opportunity by failing to invest in a contest thought to be unwinnable.
Similarly, in Florida, party officials expected Democrat Angie Nixon to fall far short against Republican Sen. Ashley Moody. She ended up losing by roughly 3 points after receiving very little in the way of financial backing from Democrats at the national level.
And then there’s Montana, where Democratic Rep.-elect Sam Forstag won a U.S. House race in impressive fashion, but where Republican Sen.-elect Kurt Alme prevailed in a three-way contest with less than 50% of the vote, leaving many Democrats in the state with a deep sense of regret. The Washington Sun reported:
The smokejumper-turned-politician pulled out an almost unbelievable win in a district President Donald Trump won handily just two years prior. But when the delirium subsided, state Democrats couldn’t help but feel that their party had squandered a rare opportunity to deliver an even bigger victory: Montana’s open Senate seat.
“It’s a missed opportunity that quite frankly sets Montana back decades,” former Democratic Sen. Jon Tester told The Washington Sun. “This was not a wave election, this was a tsunami.”
Another Montana Democrat, former Gov. Brian Schweitzer, summarized his impression with one word. “S–––show,” he told Talking Points Memo.
The political details get a little messy, but at the heart of the matter was the three-way split: Many leading Democrats, including Jon Tester, rallied behind independent Seth Bodnar, believing he had a real chance of success against Alme. That said, there was a Democratic primary, Alani Bankhead prevailed, and to the relief of Republicans everywhere, she refused to bow out and leave a one-on-one race.
“More than 200 people have emailed asking me to drop out,” Bankhead wrote in a Washington Post op-ed published less than a month before Election Day. “Twenty-two Democratic state legislators signed a letter urging me to quit. Then came the calls. A sitting U.S. senator offered me a job, presumably if I would leave the race. A sitting Democratic governor called and asked me to step aside. Former Montana governor Steve Bullock, a Democrat, invited me to coffee. And a former Cabinet official left a voicemail offering to ‘be a sounding board.’ I refused them all.”
A few days later, Shannon O’Brien resigned as chair of the Montana Democratic Party and threw her support behind Bodnar.
The results were predictable: Bankhead finished a distant third, winning roughly 12% support, though if those same voters had backed the independent as Democratic officials had hoped, Bodnar would have been well positioned to flip the seat and deny Republicans a victory.
“Speculation is always dangerous. I mean I think you look at the numbers,” Bodnar told Talking Points Memo when asked if he thought he would have won if Bankhead dropped out. “And what I do know is, add those up and I think it’s a tossup of a race. At least it’s a tossup — I think we’ve got a very, very good shot at winning.”
We’ll never know, of course, though as Democrats dream of a 60-seat majority, the conversation about Louisiana, Florida and Montana is likely to linger for a while.
The post Democrats will soon have 56 senators — and they came very close to winning even more seats appeared first on MS NOW.
From MS Now.

Leave a Reply