The GOP suffered a historic rout in the 2026 midterm elections, driven in large part by voter concerns about affordability and the increasing cost of living. So you would think the last thing any Republican would want to do is make life harder for millions of Americans by once again embracing the unpopular cause of doing away with Social Security.
You would think wrong — at least when it comes to Wisconsin Sen. Ron Johnson. He let it be known Wednesday that he was not giving up the fight, calling Social Security “grotesque” and a “Ponzi scheme” during a Fox Business spot on Wednesday morning. “You can’t fix it,” Johnson declared. “You just shut it down and hope you can recover some of your money.”
Americans, Johnson added, would be better off invested in the stock market.
By Wednesday afternoon, Johnson was running away from his remarks. “I was talking about Ponzi schemes,” Johnson said when challenged in a Senate committee hearing. “I’m not proposing shutting down Social Security,” he claimed just hours after proposing shutting down Social Security.
Minus their Social Security checks, nearly half of Americans over age 65 would live in poverty, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
Johnson has been calling Social Security a Ponzi scheme since he first ran for Senate in 2010. His argument, as made on Fox Business, is that “your benefits will be paid for by your children and grandchildren, and now money borrowed from the public.” (Never mind that a key ingredient of Ponzi schemes is the promise of fantastical returns far beyond what a social program promises.) In 2022 he even suggested making Social Security spending subject to annual congressional appropriations. “If you qualify for an entitlement, you get it no matter what the cost,” he complained.
Johnson’s remarks are but one example of almost a century’s worth of conservative attacks on this popular retirement program, one that allows millions of senior citizens to live lives of financial dignity. Minus their Social Security checks, almost half of Americans over age 65 would live in poverty, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
It should come as no surprise to discover that the issue of “money borrowed from the public” is of less concern to Johnson and other Social Security truthers when it comes to America’s millionaires and billionaires. He voted last year in favor of Trump’s budget-busting tax cut, which showered gimmes and breaks on the richest Americans and sent the budget deficit soaring, even after historic cuts to programs like Medicaid.
If Johnson and others who think like him were truly concerned about Social Security’s financing, they would note that raising or eliminating the payroll tax cap — currently set at $184,500 — would go a long way toward stabilizing the Social Security trust fund, particularly when combined with levying Social Security taxes on such investment income as dividends and capital gains. The last major reform of Social Security, in the 1980s, was devised when just less than 90% of Americans’ wages were subject to the payroll tax cap, and the reforms implemented then were designed assuming that share remained constant. Instead it has fallen to 83%, as wage growth concentrated at the top tiers of the income pyramid resulted in a greater share of total wages going to workers earning more than the cap. At least some Republicans are beginning to acknowledge this, with Ohio Sen. Bernie Moreno and Rep. Tom Cole, among others, announcing that they are open to raising or eliminating the payroll tax cap.
Perhaps one reason those Republicans are admitting this fiscal reality is because of a political reality: Americans love Social Security. I mean love. In a poll conducted by research firm Public First for the Bipartisan Policy Center, more than 90% of respondents said Social Security was a “valuable federal program.” There is no groundswell of Americans looking for Social Security to be done away with or privatized. In a 2024 Pew Research Center poll, 83% of Democrats and 77% of Republicans opposed any cuts to benefits. And suggesting the stock market as an alternative when it appears likely the market is in yet another bubble, this one driven by investment in artificial intelligence, is foolhardy.
It’s true that the Social Security trust fund is projected to run out in the early 2030s. But contra the mythology, that does not mean the program is going bankrupt.
Attacks on Social Security aren’t the only threat to Americans’ retirement. The Trump administration has opened up 401(k)s to such highly speculative investments as private credit and private equity funds — not to mention scammy cryptocurrency — all in the name of “democratization.” When Sens. Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren sent a letter to the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Department of Labor protesting the move, not a single Republican senator signed it. In reality, it increasingly seems like the American public will become the buyer of last resort for the AI bubble, allowing the billionaires to cash out at our expense while those of us who need a Social Security check will be left holding the bag.
It’s true that the Social Security trust fund is projected to run out in the early 2030s. But contra the mythology, that does not mean the program is going bankrupt. Rather, it means there will be a shortfall for lawmakers to address by either increasing taxes or even simply paying for benefits out of the general funds. It’s an important issue that needs to be treated very seriously — and not left to disingenuous figures like Johnson who clearly value ideological hatred of Social Security over the truth.
The post Voters were loud and clear on Election Day. Ron Johnson wasn’t listening. appeared first on MS NOW.
From MS Now.

Leave a Reply