Ask Jordan: What can Congress do about gerrymandering that the Supreme Court would allow?

“Does Congress have the power to pass a bill that would prohibit racial and partisan gerrymandering? And if challenged, could such a law be overturned by the Supreme Court?” – Amy

Hi Amy,

The Supreme Court handles racial and partisan gerrymandering differently, so we should analyze them separately.

Starting with racial gerrymandering, the court has already ruled that it is unconstitutional. In terms of congressional power on the subject, it depends on what any new legislation would aim to do, exactly, but this court would likely be skeptical of further attempts to protect minority voting rights.

That skepticism was evident most recently in last term’s “demolition” (as dissenting Justice Elena Kagan called it) of the Voting Rights Act in Louisiana v. Callais. The court has embraced a “colorblind” approach that treats racial considerations as constitutionally offensive regardless of their motivation.

Partisan gerrymandering is a different story. In a 2019 case called Rucho v. Common Cause, the majority said that federal courts can’t even consider those challenges because they present a “political question” the judiciary isn’t fit to answer.

Yet the court explicitly left open the possibility of a congressional solution. After listing bills on the matter that had been introduced by lawmakers over the years, the majority said it wasn’t pre-emptively approving such antipartisan proposals should they pass, but it made the general observation that the legislative path “remains open.”

Of course, we can’t guarantee how the court will decide any case. But if we take what it said in Rucho seriously, then partisan gerrymandering is something that Congress can address if it chooses to right that antidemocratic wrong.

Kagan, who also led the dissent in Rucho, cast the majority’s congressional option as a thin reed on which to hang what she saw as an abandonment of judicial responsibility.

The Obama appointee noted that what all the bills the majority cited have in common is that none of them were passed into laws. She seemed to doubt they ever will be.

“The politicians who benefit from partisan gerrymandering are unlikely to change partisan gerrymandering,” she wrote, adding that “because those politicians maintain themselves in office through partisan gerrymandering, the chances for legislative reform are slight.”

We’ll see if the new incoming Democratic congressional majority changes that outlook.

Please submit “Ask Jordan” questions through this form for a chance to have your question featured in a future edition of the Deadline: Legal newsletter.

The post Ask Jordan: What can Congress do about gerrymandering that the Supreme Court would allow? appeared first on MS NOW.

Source Author
Author: Source Author

From MS Now.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *