Welcome back, Deadline: Legal newsletter readers. President Donald Trump wants the Supreme Court to revive his lawsuit against Hillary Clinton over an alleged conspiracy against him in the 2016 election. One reason the lower courts have rejected his suit is that he waited too long to bring it, in 2022. He says he should be forgiven for the delay because he was laser-focused on the presidency in his first term.
But in a recent court filing urging the justices to stay out of it, Clinton’s lawyers pointed to all the other litigation Trump initiated while in office. “Trump filed a slew of lawsuits in his personal capacity during both of his presidential terms,” they recalled.
One of those other suits is the focus of this week’s newsletter. It produced a notable court order on Thursday, with a Florida judge delivering a partial win for the president that a press freedom group said was only made possible by distorting landmark Supreme Court precedent.
The case stems from Trump’s complaint against The New York Times, three of its journalists and Penguin Random House over two articles and a book that he has alleged were defamatory. One of the articles (“The Star-Making Machine That Created ‘Donald Trump’”) and the book (“Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father’s Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success”) were authored by Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner. The other article (“For Trump, a Lifetime of Scandals Heads Toward a Moment of Judgment”) was by Peter Baker.
In his complaint, Trump’s lawyers argued that those publications tarnished his “hard-earned professional reputation, which he painstakingly built for decades as a private citizen before becoming President of the United States, including as a successful businessman and as star of the most successful reality television show of all time — The Apprentice.”
When they moved to dismiss the case, the press defendants argued that Trump failed to show “actual malice,” as required by the landmark precedent New York Times v. Sullivan. Under that 1964 ruling, plaintiffs who are public figures must show that defendants made the allegedly defamatory statement “with knowledge that it was false or with reckless disregard of whether it was false or not.”
Trump-aligned figures have unsuccessfully tried to persuade the justices to consider reversing or narrowing that precedent. One of the court’s recent refusals to do so came against Alan Dershowitz’s bid to revive his suit against CNN over its coverage of his legal representation of Trump.
U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday began his order on Thursday by citing the Sullivan precedent. “No party disagrees” that it governs the case, the George H.W. Bush appointee in Tampa wrote. Yet he observed that the plaintiff and the defendants “debate exactly how Times v. Sullivan and intervening precedent apply” to this case.
Against that backdrop, Merryday said that Trump’s suit can’t move forward as to many of the statements he complained about, but that it can proceed as to seven of them. Most of the surviving statements are from the book, including one that said the president “had received the equivalent of more than $400 million from his father, much of it through fraudulent tax evasion schemes.” Another statement is from one of the articles, which said the authorities “looked into his ties with the Mafia, found violations of money laundering rules and penalized him for skirting stock trade rules.”
When it comes to those seven statements, Merryday wrote, Trump’s claims raised “at least a plausible inference” that the defendants knew they needed a formal legal expert opinion but failed to obtain that expertise.
The judge reached that conclusion notwithstanding the journalists’ reliance on experts, including one who called the conduct at issue “highly suspicious” and potentially criminal, and another who said it “smells like a crime.” The press defendants said in a motion ahead of Merryday’s ruling that relying on experts as they did “controverts actual malice — particularly when, as here, Plaintiff makes no effort to challenge such reliance.”
Yet Merryday said the defendants failed to rely on sufficiently thorough expertise. The judge said the experts gave “superficial” thoughts that fell short of what he said was the “formal legal opinion” needed when discussing complex subjects. He concluded that the journalistic flaw, as he saw it, “is a fine example of the purposeful avoidance of the truth, a knowing failure that remains actionable, even after Times v. Sullivan.”
A Trump spokesperson said the “momentous ruling is a victory for honesty in America.” A Times spokesperson applauded the part of the judge’s ruling dismissing Trump’s case while expressing confidence in ultimate vindication on the remaining claim, which the Times said “has no legal merit.” A Penguin spokesperson likewise said the company was “confident that the evidence in this case will lead to a full dismissal.”
Such a dismissal is possible, given that the judge’s ruling is only a preliminary one that lets the case proceed as to those statements. It’s not a ruling about whether Trump is going to win or lose the case in the end, it just says that he doesn’t lose it completely right now.
In the meantime, a free press organization warned about the dangers of judges playing editor.
Freedom of the Press Foundation’s advocacy chief, Seth Stern, said after Merryday’s ruling that it “completely misconstrues” the actual-malice standard. “The whole point of standard,” Stern said, “is to give the press breathing room to do its job and prevent judges from micromanaging journalists’ reporting processes.”
He said that if editorial judgment were controlled by individual judges “who don’t know the first thing about journalism, the press will be forced to walk on eggshells when reporting on the powerful, and the public will suffer.”
Subscribe to the Deadline: Legal newsletter for expert analysis on the top legal stories of the week, including updates from the Supreme Court and developments in the Trump administration’s legal cases.
The post Did a Florida judge ‘misconstrue’ Supreme Court precedent in Trump’s favor? appeared first on MS NOW.
From MS Now.

Leave a Reply