The debate over the U.S. war with Iran has sparked a multifaceted debate, but there’s one element of the public discussion that ought to be entirely straightforward: the number of U.S. service members who’ve died as part of the conflict.

But even this basic detail has become a point of unexpected and unnecessary contention. The New York Times reported:

The Pentagon has again quietly raised the number of U.S. service members killed and wounded during operations related to the Iran war amid widening criticism over the lack of transparency about the conflict’s human and operational costs.

The military now is reporting that 21 U.S. service members have been killed, up from 18, and 865 wounded, up by 98 since August.

The Defense Department didn’t issue a public statement about the change. Rather, late Friday — a time frequently utilized by politicians to release information they hope will go unnoticed — the Pentagon revised its data on its Defense Casualty Analysis System website.

This is not a situation in which the total number of fatalities grew because more Americans were killed as part of their mission. Rather, in this instance, the DOD increased its tally by counting casualties that weren’t included before late Friday afternoon.

This was the latest development in a controversy that started to unfold in July. While there was seemingly no meaningful debate about how many U.S. troops had died as part of the war with Iran — 18 American service members, the public was told — had made the ultimate sacrifice — the Defense Department decided to change its official online tally of fatalities.

The total of 18 was reduced to 14, reportedly because administration officials decided that the most recent deaths occurred after Donald Trump had declared a temporary ceasefire, so they literally did not count.

Not surprisingly, veterans and the loved ones of the fallen service members were not pleased, though a Pentagon spokesperson argued that the change reflected “temporary data disruptions” and “site anomalies.”

A few days later, those “anomalies” were addressed, but not well: The DOD’s DCAS continued to show a total of 14 fatalities despite having shown 18 less than a week earlier. This dovetailed, though, with a separate online page that listed “overseas operations casualties” and documented the other four service members who had died as part of the war with Iran.

To know how many American troops have died as part of the combat operations, people were apparently supposed to visit both online lists and then do the math.

Two months later, a related question emerged: Was 18 even the correct total? The Washington Post reported that there were other fatalities that the Pentagon had decided not to count.

At the time, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth called that reporting “a complete lie” in a social media post. The former Fox News host added that the Post is “worse than Iranian state media.”

Nearly a month later, the department Hegseth leads quietly reversed course, revised its total and effectively conceded that the Post’s article was correct after all.

Two leading Democratic lawmakers — Rep. Adam Smith of Washington, the ranking member on the House Armed Services Committee, and Rep. Chrissy Houlahan of Pennsylvania, the ranking member on the House panel on military personnel — issued a joint statement, noting that it was their work that exposed the discrepancy in the first place.

“There is no excuse for a mistake of this magnitude,” the members wrote. “While we take seriously our duty to serve as the voice of the American people and hold the executive branch accountable as a co-equal branch of government, requiring Congress to step in to rectify such an egregious error is an embarrassment for the Department. The failure of Secretary Hegseth to immediately take ownership of the problem also does a grave disservice to the men and women putting their lives on the line in service to our country.”

Smith and Houlahan added, “We are glad to see the error has been corrected, and we will continue to fight for transparency and accountability. While this public correction is an important first step, we expect the Department to make the necessary changes to policies and procedures to ensure this mistake is not repeated and that they are more transparent with the public going forward.”

Hegseth hasn’t yet commented publicly on the latest shift, but in a statement to the Post, the Pentagon said it’s making further revisions to how DCAS reports casualties. The statement did not acknowledge the changed numbers.

This post updates our related earlier coverage.

The post Hegseth’s Pentagon quietly reverses course, revises tally of U.S. war fatalities appeared first on MS NOW.

Author: Source Author

From MS Now.