Clarence Thomas has ‘serious doubts’ about gun restrictions in ‘sensitive places’

Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas has “serious doubts” about bans on people carrying guns in sensitive places like mass transit and hospitals.

He expressed those doubts in a statement published Monday morning in connection with the court’s refusal to consider a Second Amendment challenge to firearm restrictions in Maryland.

Thomas agreed with his colleagues that the appeal in Novotny v. Moore didn’t warrant high court review. He said the “breadth” of the challenge would have made for a complicated case. Yet he added that in an “appropriate and more narrowly focused case” in the future, the court should scrutinize states’ power to ban guns in “sensitive places.”

Noting that Maryland is one of several states that bar “law-abiding gun owners from carrying firearms in a wide variety of public places,” Thomas said he has “serious doubts that our Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation supports many of these sweeping restrictions.” He concluded that the court should someday consider “whether particular sensitive-place laws are consistent with the right to public carry.”

Thomas’ statement further cements his status as the court’s most ardent gun rights proponent.

He authored the landmark 2022 Bruen ruling that further expanded the court’s recognition of those rights, setting forth a test that restrictions can’t stand unless they’re consistent with the country’s “historical tradition of firearm regulation.” The Bruen test has proved confusing for lower courts. Even Thomas’ Republican-appointed colleagues have not always joined him in how he applies it, leaving him as the lone dissenter from a 2024 ruling that approved gun restrictions for people who pose a credible threat of domestic violence.

His statement in the Novotny case appeared on the court’s order list, which is a document that announces the latest action on pending petitions seeking high court review. Most petitions are denied and usually aren’t accompanied by any comment from the justices, hence the noteworthiness when they share their thoughts, as Thomas did Monday. It takes four justices to grant review of a petition.

Thomas’ statement comes as the court has agreed to consider this term whether there is a Second Amendment right to have AR-15s and similar semiautomatic rifles. The court is scheduled to hold a hearing on the subject next month and is expected to decide the matter by July. Thomas had been pressing his colleagues to take up the AR-15 issue, and he will likely be a vote to back that right this term.

Monday’s order list also included a dissent by Thomas from the court’s refusal to consider a First Amendment issue, stemming from California’s rule that private medical education courses must discuss, as he wrote, “how so-called implicit bias affects healthcare outcomes.” Joined by Justice Samuel Alito, Thomas wrote in Khatibi v. Yip that he would have granted review to “clarify the government-speech doctrine.” Justice Neil Gorsuch noted that he also wanted to grant review, but he did not join Thomas’ dissent.

Thomas and Alito, the court’s two senior-most justices, have been the subject of retirement speculation, especially since Democrats won a Senate majority in the midterm elections. Yet both justices have indicated that they do not intend to step down in the lame-duck period to give President Donald Trump and the outgoing GOP-majority Senate a chance to confirm their replacements. Their apparent decision to stick around ties them to the court for an indefinite period in which their successors could be determined by Democrats.

In the meantime, Monday’s order list confirms that they continue to be the court’s most conservative justices. And they continue to signal that they think there is more work for them to do on the court, or at least for them to influence how that work gets done in the future.

The post Clarence Thomas has ‘serious doubts’ about gun restrictions in ‘sensitive places’ appeared first on MS NOW.

Source Author
Author: Source Author

From MS Now.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *