A volley of letters fired off Wednesday by Rep. Robert Garcia to several current and former high-level Trump administration officials marks an early step in what congressional Democrats hope to make a sweeping investigation of the president’s policies — particularly his mass deportation campaign.
Democrats will enter the new Congress claiming a mandate from voters after an election shaped in no small part by Americans’ reaction to episodes of violence involving federal immigration officers.
Those affected and their advocates have high expectations for the investigations led by Garcia, D-Ca., the incoming chair of the House Oversight Committee, whose letter to newly named White House chief of staff Stephen Miller — the architect of President Donald Trump’s immigration policy — asserts the committee’s intentions to probe “violence, abuse, and corruption carried out by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) at your direction.”
But the prospect of congressional scrutiny also raises questions about what these investigations can realistically accomplish, and on what timeline. While Democrats will have broad powers to demand documents, compel testimony and expose wrongdoing, Congress cannot itself bring criminal charges or force the executive branch to prosecute its own officials. And an administration that has repeatedly resisted judicial and congressional oversight is unlikely to cooperate willingly.
“We’re certainly in a better position than we were before the election,” said outgoing Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty, the chief prosecutor in Minneapolis, whose investigations of the killings of Renée Good and Alex Pretti by immigration officers have been stymied by lack of cooperation from the federal government.
“But a lot depends on the details. Will the Trump administration comply? And will the Democrats treat this as a mandate and really push for what people voted for?” she said.
An infamous prison
On the list of actions that advocates are hoping Congress will scrutinize are the March 2025 deportations of hundreds of Venezuelan migrants to an infamous prison in El Salvador under the Alien Enemies Act, an obscure law from the early years of the American republic. The deportations (which are at the center of my forthcoming book, “Trial Run: How Trump’s War on Immigrants Threatens Us All”) were one of the first indications of how far the Trump administration was prepared to go in pursuit of mass deportations.
As planes carrying the deportees were in the air, U.S. District Judge James Boasberg ordered the administration to turn them around. But the planes continued to El Salvador, where the men were incarcerated at the Center for the Confinement of Terrorism, or CECOT, a prison built for hardened gang members.
Boasberg started examining whether to hold administration officials in contempt for ignoring his order, but his effort was halted by a Trump-appointed majority on an appeals court. A similar scenario could play out in a Democrat-controlled Congress, with hard questions asked but consequences comparatively few.
In the immediate aftermath of the flights, Miller described the men sent to El Salvador as “terrorists” who “relish in torture and murder,” alleging they belonged to the Venezuelan street gang Tren de Aragua. Then-Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, who was sent one of Garcia’s letters Wednesday, flew down for a photo op with shirtless, tattooed men — not the Venezuelans, but rather convicted Salvadorans — crowded into a cell behind her.
Under the Alien Enemies Act, the Venezuelans were deported without court hearings of any kind. In the weeks that followed, it became clear that most had no criminal record, and the government’s claims of gang membership fell apart under scrutiny.
In “Trial Run,” I suggest that the Alien Enemies Act deportations were an early test of the Trump administration’s ability to strip a marginalized group of fundamental legal protections and exercise unchecked executive power.
“We need to have public hearings on the record in which Trump administration officials are held accountable, and in which it’s clear as day what happened when they chose to break the law and send people to be tortured in El Salvador,” said Lindsay Toczylowski, the co-founder and CEO of Immigrant Defenders Law Center, or ImmDef, a nonprofit law firm that represents several of the Venezuelans.
The deportees spent four months at CECOT, during which they said they underwent near-constant beatings and torture. (The Trump administration has consistently maintained, in spite of the evidence, that the men sent to CECOT were dangerous gang members.) The possibility of a Democratic congressional majority investigating that is “a step forward,” said Andry Hernández Romero, a makeup artist and hairdresser who was among the CECOT deportees and whose case became emblematic for many Americans of the extraordinary injustice of the operation. “It opens up the possibility, at least, that there might be justice.”
Good and Pretti
In Minneapolis, where federal immigration agents shot Good and Pretti during a series of sweeps called “Operation Metro Surge,” the prospect of congressional investigations has taken on particular urgency: Congress might be able to obtain evidence that has so far been withheld from state and local officials.
“What I hope for is that somehow, as a result of a congressional hearing, the evidence that we don’t have would be given to us,” said Moriarty, the prosecutor.
Similarly, attorneys representing Good’s family said they hope congressional investigations can further their own lawsuits against the federal government, particularly when it comes to establishing high-level responsibility for what happened.
“One of the things that has to come out of oversight, without question, is supervisory accountability,” said Antonio Romanucci, a lawyer for the Good family. “It must start from the top, and someone has to take responsibility.”
Romanucci said his firm has had a hard time serving Miller — who reportedly lives on a military base outside Washington — with a subpoena in the family’s lawsuit. A subpoena from the House Oversight Committee would not be so easy to avoid.
Nevertheless, Moriarty and others cautioned against expecting anything other than resistance and obstruction from the Trump administration. Miller and other officials could claim executive immunity from congressional investigations, and they could bog down the process in appeals. This would be of a piece, Moriarty said, with the administration’s approach to the law.
“They’re willing to do things that are against the law and just challenge a court to decide differently,” she said.
Accountability, if not change
With Trump still in the White House, and with the ascension of Miller to chief of staff, advocates and attorneys have been careful to warn their clients and others in immigrant communities that there are limits to what Congress can accomplish.
“Accountability is different than ending mass deportations,” said Toczylowski of ImmDef, whose firm represents thousands of immigrants caught up in the crackdown.
The Trump administration turbocharged immigration enforcement with hundreds of billions of dollars in new funding. The agents, detention space and other initiatives the money is used to fund will not stop because Democrats have a majority in Congress.
Moreover, the Trump administration has made significant structural changes to much of the immigration enforcement system, including purging immigration courts of judges seen as sympathetic to immigrants and replacing them with hard-liners.
“We still have all of that machine that they built to move people quickly towards deportation,” Toczylowski said. “Those are the things that are harder for me to see changing in the short term, particularly with Stephen Miller now fully in charge.”
For Hernández, the Venezuelan man deported to CECOT, justice will not truly be done unless he is allowed to continue the asylum proceedings that were interrupted when Trump invoked the Alien Enemies Act to deport him, an action that federal courts have ruled constituted a violation of due process. Whether Hernández and the others are allowed to return to the U.S. is a question currently being decided in the courts — not a question that can be resolved by Congress.
“My goal isn’t for justice to be done while I’m still far away,” said Hernández, who is now living in Spain. “For me, justice would mean being back in the United States.”
At a minimum, those affected by Trump’s campaign of mass deportations said congressional hearings can establish a definitive historical record of everything that’s happened since Trump resumed office.
“Those hearings alone are not going to change what happened,” Toczylowski said. “But they are the beginning of making sure that it never happens again.”
The post Democrats eye a reckoning on ICE tactics and mass deportation appeared first on MS NOW.
From MS Now.

Leave a Reply