Fresh off a sweeping midterm election victory, congressional Democrats have pledged to “end” an unpopular war in the Middle East by defunding it. Sound familiar? It should: that’s exactly what Democrats promised to do regarding the Iraq War in 2006 after delivering an electoral “thumping” to President George W. Bush. Leading Democratic presidential contenders like Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton and Joe Biden all put forward their own bills that conditioned continued funding for the war on some sort of U.S. withdrawal within a specific time frame.
But extracting the United States from a foolish, misbegotten war 20 years ago proved far easier said than done — especially for Congress. And the same is true today.
If Democrats successfully cut off war funding, moreover, they would only dilute Trump’s own personal liability for perhaps the greatest strategic blunder in American history.
After the 2006 midterms, Bush chose instead to escalate the war and surged tens of thousands of American troops to Iraq — all while congressional efforts to defund the war went nowhere. These additional U.S. troops helped tamp down the violence enough for Bush to negotiate a withdrawal agreement with the Iraqi government, a deal Obama later consummated in 2011. But after the bloody rise of the Islamic State, U.S. troops returned in 2014 and maintained a presence in Iraq until this past September.
Granted, today’s circumstances differ markedly from those that prevailed two decades ago: Democrats already have much larger majorities in both houses of Congress, and unlike Iraq, the war with Iran has never commanded public support. But the strategic stakes are higher: President Donald Trump’s decision to start a war with no clear goals and for no discernible reason has left the Strait of Hormuz — one of the world’s most vital waterways — at the mercy of a hostile regime in Tehran. Defunding American combat operations in the gulf would leave the strait under the regime’s effective control.
Though Middle East energy producers are planning to build pipelines to bypass the strait, these projects will take time to complete, cannot completely replace the waterway and remain vulnerable to attacks from Iran and its proxies. Iran will have a permanent stranglehold over a critical artery of global commerce while grievously undermining the long-held American principle of the freedom of the seas.
Nor is there any guarantee that cuts to funding would actually “end” the war. Without some sort of negotiated agreement with Tehran, fighting could resume whenever the regime sees fit. The precise nature of any congressional funding restrictions raises practical questions as well: would American forces remaining in and around the gulf be able to use force to defend themselves against Iranian attacks? Would this elimination of funding require the U.S. military to leave the region entirely? What if Tehran charges tolls on seaborne traffic through the strait and attacks ships that refuse to pay? And so on.
If Democrats successfully cut off war funding, moreover, they would only dilute Trump’s own personal liability for perhaps the greatest strategic blunder in American history. The war with Iran remains deeply unpopular with the American people, and right now they correctly hold Trump entirely responsible for it. Rather than leaving Trump to take all responsibility for this strategic disaster, Democrats risk assuming some of that liability themselves. Trump dead-enders and opportunistic Republicans will likely turn that element of culpability into a pernicious myth: that a perfidious Democratic Congress snatched a humiliating defeat from the jaws of victory. If the Iran war is already truly lost, as some foreign policy analysts say it is, better to make sure that Trump takes complete blame for the catastrophe than spread it around.
The fundamental problem remains that Trump and his administration have trapped the U.S. in a war it can neither win nor afford to lose
As a result, Democrats are in a far more precarious political position than they seem to realize. Still, it’s possible that Democrats will be able to have their cake and eat it, too, when it comes to the war. Trump will likely veto any attempt to restrict his ability to use military force against Iran, and even with last week’s sweeping Democratic victories, it’s unlikely that they will muster the two-thirds majorities required in both houses of Congress to override it. That leaves Democrats with unenviable political alternatives: shut down the government over the issue, try and negotiate some lesser restrictions or accept temporary defeat.
If they accept temporary defeat — with or without some curbs on Trump’s ability to wage war in the Middle East — Democrats can credibly claim to have done what they could to “end the war” without accepting any responsibility, however partial, for its outcome.
And there are other promising ways to hold this administration accountable for its ill-conceived, unwinnable war. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, who will likely be the next speaker, has backed efforts to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, for instance, and relevant committees should exercise greater and stricter scrutiny of U.S. Central Command, which runs military operations in the Middle East (CENTCOM’s head, Adm. Brad Cooper, inexplicably decided now was the right time to launch a podcast).
In the end, though, the fundamental problem remains that Trump and his administration have trapped the U.S. in a war it can neither win nor afford to lose — and Congress cannot simply legislate an end to it.
The post Democrats want to end the Iran war. It’s easier said than done. appeared first on MS NOW.
From MS Now.

Leave a Reply