Judge considers clearing the way for Kennedy Center closure

A federal judge is considering whether to clear a key legal roadblock, which would allow the Trump administration to close the Kennedy Center for repairs and renovation for two years.

U.S. District Judge Christopher “Casey” Cooper heard arguments for over two hours on Thursday over whether to dissolve his own court order that has blocked the Trump administration, temporarily, from immediately closing the famed performing arts center.

Cooper did not indicate when he would rule on the motion, but he acknowledged he would try and rule as soon as he could.

The judge asked pointed questions of both parties as to why he should or should not clear the way for the Trump administration to close the Kennedy Center.

The Justice Department was asked about the difference between a proposed four-year plan to close the center for renovations versus a plan to close it for two years. Cooper pressed William Jankowski, who argued on behalf of the government in court Thursday, on why the two-year plan was not proposed as an option when asking Congress for the funds.

Jankowski repeatedly argued that the two-year closure was the “best path forward.”

“The board’s decisions here were reasonable and they must stand,” Jankowski said.

Cooper pressed the plaintiffs on how it would benefit the Kennedy Center to leave it open with no performances while undergoing the renovation. The judge said a four-year plan under this proposal could end up “hemorrhaging” more funds from the center.

“What good would it be to leave the center open when there’s no performances scheduled or booked?” Cooper asked the plaintiffs. “Wouldn’t that cause even more financial deterioration at this point, regardless of who is to blame for it?”

Nathaniel Zelinsky, who argued on behalf of the plaintiffs in court, said that they have raised concerns about a lack of performances and have noted the four-year renovation will cost more.

The courtroom was filled Thursday with local Washington residents who oppose the proposed renovations for the Kennedy Center. Rep. Joyce Beatty was seated at the plaintiffs table.

After the hearing, Beatty expressed confidence that the law is on her side.

“We’re winning, and we’re going to continue to fight to keep it open, keep it from being demolished,” she said.

Norm Eisen, a lawyer representing Beatty, acknowledged there was tough questioning from Cooper but added that has been the case all along.

“The most important takeaway: There is no question in my mind that this judge, under any circumstances, is going to allow the demolition of the Kennedy Center — just that East Wing or East Potomac Golf Course wrecking ball-chainsaw scenario,” he said.

“We’re fighting above all to prevent that snap destruction,” Eisen added.

The hearing came after the Trump administration asked Cooper to void the part of his May ruling, which blocked the administration from taking steps to close the Kennedy Center on the basis of an earlier board decision.

Cooper found the Kennedy Center’s board likely breached its duties by deciding to close the Kennedy Center before it had weighed its full statutory obligations, had gathered sufficient information and had robbed trustees of meaningful say ahead of the vote to close the center.

Lawyers from the Justice Department asked Cooper to dissolve that court order, saying they have taken the appropriate steps to address each of Cooper’s issues with their decision to close. They said the Kennedy Center board was given a detailed project plan, along with the recommendation of two sets of consultants, before it voted in August to close. The board voted a second time in September after receiving additional materials that the Trump administration has said support closure.

“The Board has been given information necessary to make a sound decision on how to safely, efficiently, and most appropriately address the Center’s dramatic structural decline,” they wrote in a court filing ahead of the hearing.

They also pointed to specific safety hazards, like the collapse of ceiling material. Absent closure for repairs, they said, the Kennedy Center will pose “significant safety concerns” for employees, artists and the public.

“The Center’s Board has decided that the prudent path forward to address the Center’s severe structural deficiencies and to give the institution the renovations it needs to thrive long into the future is to temporarily close its main building to conduct substantial renovations,” they wrote. “This Court should lift the last impediment in place preventing that outcome.”

Lawyers representing Beatty, the congresswoman who brought the lawsuit, pushed back on those claims, saying the Trump-picked Kennedy Center director “concocted a sham process to lend a false patina of legitimacy to their decision” to close the center. Lawyers for Beatty alleged that the Trump administration picked information and experts to “validate Trump’s foreordained outcome, regardless of facts and what is best for the Kennedy Center.”

“Defendants have persisted in making a mockery of their fiduciary obligations,” lawyers for Beatty wrote in a filing ahead of the hearing. “They fall well short of the tall burden required to take the extraordinary step of dissolving the preliminary injunction, which would reward egregious conduct and threaten the Kennedy Center’s future.”

In May, when Cooper temporarily blocked the administration from closing the Kennedy Center, he also permanently blocked the Trump administration from changing the name of the performing arts center to honor President Donald Trump or anyone other than former President John F. Kennedy.

But Cooper is only considering whether to dissolve the ruling that prevents immediate closure. The government has not asked him to lift the order that blocked the renaming of the Kennedy Center.

The post Judge considers clearing the way for Kennedy Center closure appeared first on MS NOW.

Source Author
Author: Source Author

From MS Now.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *