Judge indefinitely blocks Trump’s arch

A federal judge indefinitely blocked the Trump administration Friday from beginning construction on President Donald Trump’s 250-foot triumphal arch. The ruling marks a major roadblock for the president’s effort to reconstruct Washington, D.C. in his own vision.

U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema issued a ruling at the end of a hearing, blocking construction of Trump’s arch. Her ruling marks the second time a federal judge has blocked construction of the arch but the first time a judge has blocked it indefinitely.

Brinkema’s ruling comes after U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan in D.C. temporarily blocked construction shortly after it had been approved by the National Capital Planning Commission earlier this month. On Wednesday, Chutkan extended her block through Dec. 3 while she continues to mull a longer-term ruling.

In her ruling which she delivered verbally from the bench, Brinkema called Trump’s construction project a “rushed job.”

The government has argued the project has congressional approval, pointing to a century-old approval for a two-column structure near the site of the proposed arch.

Brinkema did not buy that argument, saying relying on that statute “hurts your credibility with the court.”

Neither the Justice Department nor the White House immediately responded to requests for comment on the ruling.

“We are pleased that the court has recognized the irreparable harm that will come to people who live and work in Arlington and stopped the massive vanity project while our case is heard and considered by the court,” said Kate Talmor, a Senior Counsel at Democracy Forward. “We are honored to work with the Arlington County Board to stop the proposed arch from jeopardizing public safety.”

The Arlington County Board in Virginia had sued to block construction, alleging that the Trump administration was moving too quickly and bypassing the full review process and noting that construction would worsen traffic and hinder emergency services.

Brinkema repeatedly pointed to that issue in court on Friday and the “huge potential impact” by construction of the arch.  She noted that emergency services and first responders for both Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport and Arlington National Cemetery need the Arlington Memorial Bridge — near the proposed location of the arch — when responding to emergencies, and construction would hinder those efforts.

The lawsuit brought by Arlington County had been simmering on the backburner as another consolidated lawsuit in D.C. had been moving through the courts more quickly. That case brought by the attorneys general of D.C. and Virginia, as well as a group of Vietnam War veterans, has already secured an order from Chutkan temporarily blocking construction.

Those groups – the attorneys general and the veterans – had argued the Trump administration lacked the authority to construct the arch and that it violates a number of federal statutes.

Several members of the Kennedy family signed on to that lawsuit, alleging the arch would permanently cast shadows over and damage historically significant sightlines to the existing gravesites and memorials established in the Kennedy family’s honor at Arlington National Cemetery near the proposed site for the arch.

“I believe this to be a disrespectful intrusion on a revertantly designed and tended site and an insult to the legacy of my family,” Rory Kennedy, a daughter of Robert F. Kennedy wrote in a court filing. “The shadow would fundamentally alter the experience of visiting the Gravesites. It will be difficult for me to recognize my parents’, uncles’, and aunt’s service and sacrifice to this country without distraction.”

Chutkan was also not convinced the government had congressional authorization. She temporarily blocked construction, finding that statute did not authorize Trump’s arch.

“The sheer improbability that a 100-year-old statute would contain authority, unknown to every previous administration, to erect a 250-foot arch at a principal location in the Nation’s capital indicates how far Defendants must stretch to justify this project,” Chutkan wrote in her ruling.

Trump unveiled his plans last year for a 250-foot Arc de Triomphe-style monument in honor of the country’s 250th anniversary. The original plans called for a towering gilded arch that would dwarf the nearby 99-foot Lincoln Memorial and other monuments in D.C.

Since the original lawsuit was filed, Trump’s plans of the arch have evolved. Last month, Trump announced that the larch would become a “top grade Military Complex/Triumphal Arch, to house, store, and have the rapid ability to use large numbers of drones, plus Snipers, on both the roof and plaza areas, and additionally have and hold large quantities of sniper ammunition and storage.”

But the final plans for the arch that were submitted publicly to the NCPC make no mention of a military complex. There are also no references to a national security purpose.

The post Judge indefinitely blocks Trump’s arch appeared first on MS NOW.

Source Author
Author: Source Author

From MS Now.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *