New advances in CTE research could bring a wave of unintended consequences

Two new studies published in the medical journal JAMA indicate that researchers have found a marker in blood samples that may eventually help detect advanced CTE in people while they are alive, potentially heralding major changes for football and all contact sports. Active athletes would have access to information they could use to determine how much longer they will play their sport, if they continue at all.

For as long as we’ve known about CTE, or chronic traumatic encephalopathy, it has only been determinable by examining a person’s brain during an autopsy. That means that no active or retired football or hockey player has ever been told by a doctor that he has CTE — because it hasn’t been knowable.

If the new findings lead to the kind of tests that scientists say they could, then NFL players, who have long said they know the risks that come with playing football, may have to answer some questions for the first time.

Someone who had CTE could expect to have problems with behavior, mood and thinking. And if the new findings lead to the kind of tests that scientists say it could, then NFL players, who have long said they know the risks that come with playing football, may have to answer some questions for the first time, including: If a blood test could tell you whether you had CTE, would you want the answer before you signed for another season?

Of the former players who had their brain donated to science, roughly 91.7% to 93.5% were found to have CTE. Players have given mixed responses when asked whether they would take such a test — and the numbers on former NFL players diagnosed with CTE postmortem are staggering. The prevalence of the disease in deceased players is such that many living players are highly likely (if not almost certain) to develop CTE, too. But hypothetical testing and testing in reality are two very different matters.

Knowing the risk of brain damage is high is different from knowing whether or not one’s brain has already been damaged.

This is objectively good news: A reliable test could give a player information about their brain that no league warning and no consultations regarding concussions ever could. But say there was a finding of CTE in an active football player. Would the exorbitant salaries in the NFL be too much to pass on?

Some players who have suffered multiple concussions may think of themselves as being a year or two away from ultimate financial freedom. Some players may see the next contract as the way to pay off a mortgage or cover their children’s college tuition. Other might think their CTE won’t be as bad as other players’ CTE or think they can defy the odds and just live with it. Of course, we would see more players making the decision to retire sooner than usual and planning earlier for a life after sports.

Michael Alonso, the co-senior author of the study at Boston University’s CTE Center, says the potential blood test could be a “game changer,” while cautioning that “we are still in the discovery phase and it’s a small sample size.”

Michael Alonso is the co-senior author of the study at Boston University’s CTE Center. He says the potential blood test could be a “game changer,” while cautioning that “we are still in the discovery phase and it’s a small sample size.” That said, my call would be for voluntary testing, a private conversation with an independent doctor and a clear explanation of what the results mean; that is, what the results can and can’t tell them. A player should be able to ask, “What does this mean for me and my family?” before having to ask, “Does my general manager already know?”

We’d all like to believe that more information is empowering for players, but such testing could ultimately bring about a whole new set of unintended consequences.

For all the questions this raises, I keep coming back to something we say pretty casually about football players: “They’ve known the risks for years.” Well, if the science gets there, a player about to sign his next contract could know something about his own health that he might have had no way of knowing when he signed his first one. Maybe he sits down with his family and decides that one more season is worth it. Maybe, for the first time in his life, he feels ready to say he’s played his last down. The decision would only be his to make.

What we should all like to see are players who get the chance to decide what to do with as much information as they want and with family and loved ones who’ll be there long after the games are over.

The post New advances in CTE research could bring a wave of unintended consequences appeared first on MS NOW.

Source Author
Author: Source Author

From MS Now.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *