Teapot Dome scandal holds lessons for U.S. prosecutor threatening lawmakers

With the exception of his military service and a brief stint at the Justice Department last year, Aaron Reitz has lived the bulk of his personal and professional life in Texas. But judging from the letters he has been sending lately as the U.S. attorney for the state’s Southern District, there is nothing particularly local about his focus.

Specifically, Reitz has sent strongly worded letters to Democratic Sens. Elissa Slotkin, Elizabeth Warren and Richard Blumenthal and Rep. Robert Garcia, all of whom have laid out plans for particular congressional oversight investigations. Reitz reminds them in those letters that any intended investigations must have a “legitimate legislative purpose” and that the powers of criminal prosecution belong not to the executive and judicial branches, not Congress.

He demands that the senators and the congressman preserve all documents and communications related to their purported attempts to intimidate or silence President Donald Trump’s “private associates,” prevent them from associating with the administration, or even deter them, as Reitz alleged in his letter to Blumenthal, from “engaging in philanthropic activities that will benefit our nation for generations.”

Ultimately, his letters suggest that members of Congress could face “significant legal consequences” for conspiring to deprive certain investigative targets of their “core constitutional rights.”

For the moment, put aside that Reitz appears to be threatening criminal investigations of people far outside his jurisdiction, and in at least one case, with highly questionable language: His letter to Warren, who has been targeted by the right for her past claims of Native American heritage, is infused with references to spears, tomahawks, scalp hunting and war cries. (Those terms do not appear in his letter to Blumenthal.)

The question, as a legal matter, is whether Reitz — a former chief of staff to Republican Sen. Ted Cruz and failed candidate to replace Ken Paxton as Texas attorney general — is just wrong.

First, the speech or debate clause of the Constitution has long been understood to protect members of Congress not only from liability, “but also from the burden of defending themselves,” as the Supreme Court noted in 1975. Once it is clear that senators or representatives are “acting within the ‘legitimate legislative sphere,’ the Speech or Debate Clause is an absolute bar to interference,” including criminal prosecution and process, the court ruled in Eastland v. United States Servicemen’s Fund, a case about the Senate investigating an anti-Vietnam War group.

Of course, Reitz is correct that congressional investigations must have a valid legislative purpose. But Congress has always had significant leeway in exercising a power the Supreme Court described as both “broad” and “indispensable,” even in a 2020 case involving Trump’s own financial and tax records.

And to understand just how wrong Reitz’s anticipatory threat letters are, it’s worth revisiting the Teapot Dome scandal, as MS NOW’s Rachel Maddow has in “Department of Fate,” her history of the Justice Department at its worst.

The rank self-dealing and corporate corruption revealed by that scandal led the Supreme Court to decide almost a century ago that Congress had not only the power to investigate an attorney general’s abuse and neglect of his duties, but also the right to enforce its subpoenas — even if it meant tracking down and placing in federal custody an uncooperative witness.

That case began in 1924, when a select committee of the Senate opened an investigation of the “alleged neglect and failure” of then-Attorney General Harry Daugherty, a notoriously close friend of and campaign manager for President Warren G. Harding, to prosecute the central figures in Teapot Dome, as well as many others accused of bribery and graft. Broadly, the committee undertook to understand what Daugherty and those working for him were actually doing that made them transparently ineffective and inefficient stewards of the public trust.

As part of that investigation, the committee issued a subpoena to Daugherty’s brother, Mal, for his testimony and a broad array of records — including those that would reflect deposits and withdrawals — for the Ohio bank where he was an executive.

When Mal Daugherty blew off the subpoena, the Senate’s deputy sergeant-at-arms tracked him down and arrested him in Cincinnati with the intent of physically bringing him back to Washington to testify. Mal succeeded in getting himself released from what amounted to Congress jail, but the Senate appealed.

In weighing whether Congress had the power to compel a witness to testify in order to “exercise a legislative function,” the Supreme Court first recognized that there was no constitutional provision “expressly investing either house with power to make investigations and exact testimony,” but that in practice, and under its own precedent, “the power of inquiry — with process to enforce it — is an essential and appropriate auxiliary to the legislative function.”

But just as significantly, the court also considered the purpose of the Senate select committee’s investigation and whether it was to obtain information for legislative reasons. And even though Mal Daugherty protested expressly that the Senate was attempting to usurp the judiciary and put his brother on trial, the Supreme Court disagreed.

Instead, it held that the investigation was appropriately focused on “the administration of the Department of Justice — whether its functions were being properly discharged or were being neglected or misdirected, and particularly whether the Attorney General and his assistants were performing or neglecting their duties.”

Ultimately, given that Congress oversees the Justice Department’s functions and the attorney general’s powers, and determines what funds are needed annually to carry out its responsibilities, the court found that it should be presumed that Congress’ “real object” was a legitimate one. The court concluded that, having ducked a subpoena in aid of a legitimate investigation, Mal Daugherty never should have been released from the custody of the Senate’s deputy sergeant-at-arms.

All told, the Daugherty case — which remains good law — suggests that Aaron Reitz might make an entertaining if vaguely menacing pen pal. But notwithstanding his boast to The Wall Street Journal that he need not wait for Congress “to commit a crime for us to begin investigating whether there’s a basis to escalate or indict or prosecute,” it appears he could use a history lesson.

Or a copy of Maddow’s book.

The post Teapot Dome scandal holds lessons for U.S. prosecutor threatening lawmakers appeared first on MS NOW.

Source Author
Author: Source Author

From MS Now.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *