Trump’s litigiousness could help doom his bid to revive Hillary Clinton suit at Supreme Court

President Donald Trump’s lawyers claim he was too busy to file a lawsuit against Hillary Clinton during his first term. The problem with that claim? All the other suits he has filed while in office.

There are actually multiple problems with that claim, as Clinton’s lawyers argue in their brief opposing Supreme Court review of the president’s bid to revive the suit.

“Trump filed a slew of lawsuits in his personal capacity during both of his presidential terms,” they noted in the brief, filed Friday. They cited several other civil cases he initiated, including litigation over his financial records in his first term and defamation complaints he launched in his second term.

That tension in the president’s position is only one of the issues that gives his lawyers a tough task in trying to persuade the justices to greenlight a case that lower courts have deemed untimely and meritless — even frivolous.

The dispute stems from Trump’s allegation that ahead of the 2016 election, his Democratic rival conspired with others to “discredit, delegitimize and defame” him with “a false narrative” that he and his campaign colluded with Russia. He filed it after he left office, in 2022, asserting that he had suffered millions of dollars in legal costs on top of lost business opportunities.

A federal judge in Florida dismissed the case, and a federal appeals court upheld the dismissal in a ruling authored by the appellate court’s chief judge, William Pryor, who was previously listed as a potential Trump Supreme Court pick.

“Many of Trump’s and Habba’s legal arguments were indeed frivolous,” Pryor wrote for the appellate panel, referring to Alina Habba Mildon, who is separately the subject of a recent ethics complaint in New Jersey. She had represented Trump during earlier litigation in the case but is not representing him at the Supreme Court. Rather, she is listed as one of the petitioners alongside the president.

On the timing point, the panel cited the Supreme Court’s 1997 ruling in Clinton v. Jones that said President Bill Clinton couldn’t avoid judicial process in civil litigation while he was in office. “If a president can be haled into court, he cannot be excused from suing to enforce his rights,” Pryor wrote.

In Trump’s petition to the justices seeking review of that appellate ruling, his lawyers said there was an important difference between suing and being sued. They wrote that Clinton v. Jones “permitted another citizen’s suit against the President while requiring respect for the Presidency; it did not require him to pursue his own claims while in office or lose them.”

They said the “unceasing demands of the Presidency led President Trump to defer private litigation, which he decided was best in order to allow him to discharge the constitutional responsibilities the American people elected him to fulfill.”

Yet in their opposition brief, Clinton and her would-be civil co-defendants observed that Trump’s history of filing other suits while in office “shows that, in Trump’s repeated estimation, filing civil suits does not interfere with his presidential duties.”

They added that the president’s delay argument fails even on its own terms because he waited another 14 months after he left office to bring the case. In any event, they said, “all of Trump’s claims resoundingly failed on the merits.”

And while the president’s lawyers attempt to tie this personal case to the presidency — writing that it “affects every future President” — Clinton’s lawyers said there has never been a president who raised the issue that Trump is pressing. “This one-off case does not merit use of the Court’s scarce judicial resources,” they told the justices.

The high court might well agree. But we don’t yet know whether it will or when it will decide. Under its rules for accepting cases, at least four justices would need to vote in favor of considering the appeal to grant review.

Despite the apparently far-fetched nature of the president’s appeal, there’s reason to think that at least one justice is taking his petition seriously. That’s because the reason the Clinton camp even had to make an argument in opposition to review is that the court asked for a response. The former secretary of state and first lady’s lawyers had initially waived the right to respond to Trump’s petition. But the court requested one instead of summarily denying the petition.

It only takes one justice to generate such a request, so it doesn’t necessarily mean there are four votes for review. When requesting responses, the court does not indicate which justice or justices initiated the request. The court asked for the response by Nov. 27, and Clinton’s lawyers filed it long before that deadline.

Now that the court has received the requested response, there isn’t a firm deadline for the justices to decide whether to grant or deny review. It will be put on for one of the justices’ upcoming private conferences at which they consider pending petitions. Trump’s lawyers will have a chance to file a final reply brief to press their case before the justices decide.

After conferencing the case at least once, the court will announce whether it is taking it up. But again, the court is not on a deadline to make that announcement, so we don’t yet know when it will come.

The president is simultaneously pressing the justices to review his appeals in separate defamation cases he has lost in the lower courts against CNN and author E. Jean Carroll.

The post Trump’s litigiousness could help doom his bid to revive Hillary Clinton suit at Supreme Court appeared first on MS NOW.

Source Author
Author: Source Author

From MS Now.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *