Vance thinks doubling-down on anti-immigrant rhetoric will work. He’s wrong.

Say what you will about JD Vance — and I have — but no one ever accused the vice president of lacking self-confidence. When it comes to the issue of immigration post-midterms, he’s typically bold in his assessment that Donald Trump’s White House is on the right track.

On Thursday, Vance lashed out at Gov. Kevin Stitt after the Oklahoma Republican called for Trump to work with the newly elected Democratic congressional majority on immigration reform. Pointing at the “huge swing in the midterms,” Stitt argued that there was a way to keep a “strong border” while making sure the U.S. had enough immigrants to meet labor market needs.

The vice president frequently invokes “amnesty” as a scare word to malign more moderate views on immigration.

That idea, Vance replied on X, “is morally and electorally disastrous,” and “to a lot of people, this sounds like an effort to give amnesty.” This echoed his warning in the immediate aftermath of the midterms that it was “gaslighting” to argue that Trump’s mass deportation efforts played a role in turning voters against Republicans.

Simply put, the vice president is wrong. Trump’s deportation agenda is broadly unpopular on its own. It has also exacerbated the economic woes that topped the list of concerns for voters. While the Trump administration seems determined to continue this inhumane policy, doing so likely will hurt the GOP nominee in 2028 — something that should worry Vance if he plans to run.

The vice president frequently invokes “amnesty” as a scare word to malign more moderate views on immigration. After boosting rumors that Haitian migrants kidnapped pets and spread disease, Vance labeled it “amnesty” to allow them to keep Temporary Protected Status. Around the same time, he demonized a Democratic bill that would allow undocumented immigrants to start a five-year process to become lawful permanent residents. He flings the word “amnesty” at legal immigrants, while also falsely accusing them of causing crime and inflation.

Saying “amnesty” all the time, however, cannot erase the exit polls that showed most Americans oppose Trump’s aggressive deportation tactics and believe immigration helps the country. Even the president, in a post-election interview with Ross Douthat of CBS News, admitted that it’s unpopular to deport “good people” who are “paying taxes,” as his administration has focused on doing.

For Trump, who can’t run for president again, there’s no personal downside to doubling down on his cruel immigration agenda. He already showed his contempt for midterm voters by promoting Stephen Miller, widely reported to be the driving force behind the mass deportations, as White House chief of staff. The lame-duck president and his right-hand man likely feel free to unleash Immigrations and Custom Enforcement on even more daycare workers, teenage clerks and parents dropping kids off at school.

Deliberately shrinking the population by millions of people, which is the stated goal of the Trump deportation campaign, is like building a giant vacuum to suck billions of dollars out of the economy.

Vance, however, is considering a presidential run. If he wants to win, he should reconsider his confidence that voters would reward a hard-line stance against their immigrant neighbors. Two more years of Trump’s deportations won’t just further offend people morally, either. The resulting economic damage will cause a lot of headaches for the next Republican nominee.

As NPR reported Thursday, immigration drives economic growth and increases the number of jobs available for everyone. Deliberately shrinking the population by millions of people, which is the stated goal of the Trump deportation campaign, is like building a giant vacuum to suck billions of dollars out of the economy. That deficit can’t be made up by American citizens having more babies, no matter how much Vance would like to pretend otherwise. Babies, while cute, don’t work jobs and pay taxes like immigrant adults do.

Vance is not required to stand by Trump’s immigration agenda. Even if he doesn’t want to be caught publicly disagreeing with Trump, as he came close to doing with the Iran war, silence is always an option. Publicly criticizing Republicans who express a desire to moderate on immigration is a choice — one Vance clearly wants to be seen making.

Since the vice president is smart enough to read a poll, this seems like an odd path to travel. But he is facing considerable pressure from right-wing media. As Media Matters documented, popular MAGA pundits like Tucker Carlson and Megyn Kelly have been pushing the Trump administration to inflict even more pain on immigrants, by making it even harder to work and earn money. On Steve Bannon’s “War Room” podcast, Heritage Foundation fellow Mike Howell called on Miller to “unleash the dragon” and “deport millions.” Anyone who spends a lot of time on X, which Vance appears to do, will see a steady drumbeat of racist vitriol against immigrants.

Wallow in these waters long enough, and you might get a distorted view of where Americans stand on this issue. But MAGA podcasts and right-wing social media chatter do not reflect the average opinion, which is far more forgiving toward undocumented immigrants and positive toward immigration in general. Right-wing pundits are loud, but the voters had their say on Election Day, and they do not like the Trump-Miller approach to immigration. If Vance takes the same approach, he’ll likely find out that it’s a political loser for him, as well.

The post Vance thinks doubling-down on anti-immigrant rhetoric will work. He’s wrong. appeared first on MS NOW.

Source Author
Author: Source Author

From MS Now.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *