Why Hakeem Jeffries’ Medicare proposal is a big deal

Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, the presumptive speaker of the House, endorsed a proposal on Tuesday that would mark a new chapter in America’s long pursuit of universal healthcare. Jeffries endorsed lowering the Medicare eligibility age (though he did not specify a particular threshold), adding hearing, dental and vision benefits to traditional Medicare, and providing for universal coverage for children.

It was, to borrow Joe Biden’s description of the Affordable Care Act, a “BFD.”

Although Donald Trump will remain president for two more years, it would be a mistake for Democrats to neglect healthcare in the new Congress. Six in 10 voters in the midterm elections were “very concerned” about healthcare costs, according to exit polls; in battleground Senate races, roughly two-thirds of voters who were worried about healthcare costs voted for Democrats; and it was the issue voters most trust Democrats to handle.

While roughly two-thirds of Americans view the government as responsible for ensuring that everyone has access to healthcare, there are multiple paths to universal access.

Political capital is precious and time-limited, however. Windows of opportunity do not stay open for long. Thus, Democrats have every incentive to work to earn the continued support of the American voter, including a healthcare affordability agenda. And should Republicans block their efforts, whether through filibuster or veto, Democrats at least will have their opponents on the record as opposing broadly popular programs.

While roughly two-thirds of Americans view the government as responsible for ensuring that everyone has access to healthcare, there are multiple paths to universal access. Consequently, there is disagreement about the optimal role (if any) for private insurance. The Democratic coalition has historically been roughly divided between those seeking to enact a public option that would compete with existing private insurance options and those preferring a single-payer approach (“Medicare for All”).

Whatever the approach, there are important questions to be asked before rolling out broad expansions of health coverage. How will Medicare perform with dramatically increased reliance on government insurance? How will the American healthcare workforce meet the dramatically increased demand for health services? And with Americans’ trust in government at record lows, how can policymakers rebuild that trust so that more people will be willing to entrust their healthcare access to the government?

These questions, taken together, are evidence in favor of meaningful but gradually implemented reforms. Even Sen. Bernie Sanders’ Medicare for All plan, for instance, would phase in a single-payer plan over four years — and the changes in the first year under Sanders’ plan, as the senator noted this week, are remarkably similar those Jeffries proposed.

In fact, Medicare itself, though momentous, was meant to be only a stepping stone toward universal health coverage. Enacted after decades of efforts toward national health insurance were defeated by cries of “socialized medicine,” Medicare and its sister program, Medicaid, showed two groups of Americans — the indigent and the elderly — how government can lend a helping hand and offer the health and economic security for which so many previously yearned.

As originally crafted, Medicare was meant to prioritize acute, higher-cost services, while expenses such as hearing, vision and dental services were deemed personal expenses for which the individual would be responsible. But exploding costs led enrollees to increasingly rely on health maintenance organizations and preferred provider organizations. Visions of Medicare expansion were supplanted; instead, policymakers focused on supplemental coverage to fill in the gaps.

Perhaps the biggest outstanding question from Jeffries’ proposal is whether this health-coverage expansion would be accompanied by measures to boost the supply of America’s healthcare workforce.

In the Balanced Budget Act of 1997, Congress created Medicare Advantage, which offers lower-premium plans with extra benefits including dental, vision and hearing. The combination (plus expensive ad campaigns) have made these plans attractive to many seniors despite their often narrow provider networks, heavy reliance on prior authorization and upcoding.

Embedding hearing, dental and vision benefits in traditional Medicare can make its plans more attractive to enrollees. By steering people away from Medicare Advantage plans, they may also be spared the administrative headaches of choosing from among roughly 30 Medicare Advantage plans. Those plans may be more likely than traditional Medicare to deny prescribed care and, in turn, necessitate burdensome appeal processes that few are well equipped to navigate.

Lowering the Medicare eligibility threshold also offers an opportunity to show a larger swath of the population — older workers who do not have employer-sponsored insurance — the gains that can come from an increased role for the government in health insurance. Those age 50 and older typically have higher-than-average health needs than do younger individuals, making healthcare access especially crucial. While just 5% of those age 55 to 64 are uninsured, many struggle with high out-of-pocket costs, putting them at risk of delayed care and financial instability. What’s more, they are the second-largest demographic group enrolled in the Affordable Care Act marketplace, and thus more vulnerable to the recent expiration of enhanced subsidies and, in turn, insurers’ rate hikes to potentially financially prohibitive degrees.

Bringing these individuals into the Medicare population — especially with these added benefits — would offer critical health and financial security for older individuals still in the workforce. And it would test Medicare’s ability to accommodate a marked increase in enrollments before further expansion, all while having the potential to rebuild trust in government as a solution.

Providing universal coverage for children would also fulfill this test, with the added benefit that children are typically healthier than older adults and are consequently less expensive to insure. And the young are a sympathetic group in political terms. (Letting children remain on their parents’ insurance, for instance, was one of the Affordable Care Act’s most popular provisions.) Universal coverage for children would help the 6% of children who are uninsured, give peace of mind to millions of families and call the bluff of self-proclaimed “family values” conservatives.

Perhaps the biggest outstanding question from Jeffries’ proposal is whether this health-coverage expansion would be accompanied by measures to boost the supply of America’s healthcare workforce. The Association of American Medical Colleges projects that the U.S. will face a physician shortage of 86,000 doctors by 2036, and that number may need to be revised upward in light of restrictive immigration policies and funding cuts. If we expand health insurance — thereby increasing demand for healthcare — without addressing the physician shortage, we’ll still struggle to deliver on the promise of meaningful healthcare access.

“The health of all its citizens deserves the help of all the Nation,” President Harry Truman declared in 1945. The fight Truman waged for national health insurance continues to this day. Jeffries has found the potential sweet spot between ambition and pragmatism, expanding governmental protection to those who need it most without demanding Americans embrace an overnight transformation of the entire health system. If Democrats can deliver tangible gains in the new year while laying the groundwork for more ambitious reforms beyond this Congress, they will make great progress toward fulfilling Truman’s long-deferred promise.

The post Why Hakeem Jeffries’ Medicare proposal is a big deal appeared first on MS NOW.

Source Author
Author: Source Author

From MS Now.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *